We received one quote for a water taxi out of Belize City, for $600 US round-trip. This seems awfully high to us.

Does anybody have any suggestions on how to get to Long Caye? Are we missing an obvious solution?

Thanks in advance!
I'm assuming your talking about the long caye at lighthouse reef with the real estate development.I wouldnt think the 600.us r/t
would not be to out of line, the Blue Hole Trip is 250.us pp.
my best advice would be to ask the real estate agent selling the property to show it to you.