I stayed a couple of days at Caye Chapel Island Resort last summer and thought it was fantastic. Expensive, but truly one of the best places in Belize (and I've stayed at close to a 100 hotels in Belize). I guess the resort and island are still for sale -- a steal at US$55 million -- but it would be an amazing place for a honeymoon.
Other great romantic honeymoon spots in Belize including Turtle Inn in Placencia, Kanantik near Hopkins, Blancaneaux Lodge and Hidden Valley Inn in the Pine Ridge, Victoria House and Portofino on Ambergris Caye, Chan Chich Lodge in Orange Walk District and Chaa Creek in Cayo.
--Lan Sluder www.belizefirst.com