OK guys, give me some suggestions:)
So far we've narrowed the choices to Tree Tops and DeReal McCaw and we are having a hard time deciding. We'd like a place on the water if possible, doesn't have to be fancy but needs to be clean, safe, comfy bed, no paper thin walls.
Help us make a choice, this is our first trip.
Thanks!

Any suggestions? Please

Try here:

http://www.cayecaulker.org/cgi-bin/Ultimate.cgi

I am told Rasta Pasta is a must, for restraunts, never been there yet. It's on Caye Caulker.

Yum, that sounds great! Sadly I am allergic to wheat so often pasta restuarants are torture for me:(

We ate at the one on CC and at Coconuts (since closed) numerous times in 2004. We were on CC for 5 days waiting for the weather to break for sailing to Placencia. Rasta Pasta and the Sandbox served us well during that time, so did the Lazy Lizard!
Recommend visiting them all!

There's lot's more than pasta including fantastic 2 meal burritos.

"Big Up Huge" burritos: YUM!

Rasta Pasta - Tangerine screwdivers - double yum!
(it's a seasonal treat)Great lobster salad and the chocolate chip macaroons, OMG, to die for!

Sounds good for the tummy, yum:)