Took a catamaran sail to Caye Caulker from Ambergis Caye almost 4 years ago and found myself wishing I'd spent my vacation on Caulker instead. Early next year my wish comes true when my girlfriend and I will be spending one glorious week there.

I've narrowed my accommodation selection down to Treetops and Jaguar Morning Star. Would greatly appreciate advice from the board as which would be the best selection. We don't like noise but we do like to be close to everything which creates a dilemma sometimes. Also, which would be the coolest temperaturewise and which would be the coolest as a place to enjoy living for a week.
Thanks!