It's a real shame that the whole Caye Caulker Population gets a bad rap, because of a few bad seeds. There are many persons who love animals here and do their best for stray dogs and cats as well as help others with the health and care of their pets.
As far as Big George and his staff is concerned, I believe they have no self respect or self esteem, for why would anyone hurt defenseless animals unless it was to magnify themselves in the own hearts? I feel only sadness that the rest of CC is brought down by their thoughtless actions.
If you want to boycott his bar, great. Better though to let him know exactly why you aren't going to be a patron.