My husband and I visited Caye Caulker last March and had a completely different experience than CayeCracker. Everyone was very nice to us and we felt safe where ever we went. Love Rasta Pasta. No, we did not have valuables with us, other than our camera, and we keep that with us all the time to take pictures. We locked our doors and windows when we left the house (just like we do in the US) and used basic common sense. You really don't need to bring much with you. Leave your jewelry at home, it just would look silly with your shorts, tank tops, and flip flops anyway! Thanks to everone in Caye Caulker for your hospitality. We will be back again this March, bringing another couple with us.