We spent 3 days on Caulker in February. There are alot of places to eat but these are a few of our favorites. BUT we didn't get to try some of the other places we have heard good things about, like Syds, Wish Willys.
The Rainbow Bar and Grill--great view, always have a shrimp burrito, so yummy. Also they have good nachos and quesadillas.
Service is good and did I mention the great view?
Ate at the Sandbox. Good food. One night my husband had a fish with garlic and mushroom dinner entree. I thought he was going to lick the plate clean, he loved it. Also ate breakfast there once, pretty good breakfast, great spicy sausage.
Another good breakfast place is Amor y Cafe. Wonderful Spanish eggs and muffins with organic peanut butter and sliced bananas.
Only open for breakfast.
The highlight for us was Habeneros Restaurant. Tucked away on Caye Caulker is a fabulous restaurant. Jerry had fish cooked in banana leafs and Mayan sauces. Very, very good. We started with the VooDoo Cakes, my goodness, so good. AND for the finishing touch, Habeneros Caye Lime dessert. So good that I can't think of a word to do it justice. Just a wonderful dinner experience on Caye Caulker.
Hope this helps!!! Caye Caulker is great, you will have a great time there.