We always include golf cart rental in our travel budget. It is a fun way to zip around and a day exploring with the golfcart is always an interesting trip!
Walking a mile in the hot tropical sun along the beach is easier relaxing and stopping for refreshment than it is trying to get some place with heavy gear to carry - especially more than once a day that is why I like the golfcart route!
By the way Pool or no Pool? Banana Beach has a courtyard pool - great for shade but not view IMO ps No Elevators on island
Also many places with good snorkeling off the docks, Amigos Del Mar, Ramons. Victoria House etc.... so the non-divers might want masks & snorkels for shore swimming. Stop for a refreshment & a snorkel just to jump in!
Stayed here nice, no pool, quiet close to town/ in town south near Ramon'shttp://ambergriscaye.com/bzreef/index.html
Always wanted to stay here - would want golfcart though
quiet and bird sanctuaryhttp://www.ambergriscaye.com/caribbeanvillas/index.html
I've heard this is a fun place to stay and close to town southhttp://ambergriscaye.com/coconuts/index.html
Two of the best deals on the island but not quiet right in town
next to Amigos Del Mar Dive Shop
stayed here rustic with nice upstairs porch & fridge no poolshttp://ambergriscaye.com/conchshell/index.html
ate good breakfast herehttp://ambergriscaye.com/lilys/index.html
Also Loved the night dive at Hol Chan with Amigos Del Mar the dive shop we usehttp://ambergriscaye.com/amigosdive/index.html
Breakfast at Estelles Dine by the Sea in the middle of town on the beach
BBQ on Beach & Lion's Club good deals. Shore Lunch awesome experience
Also save $$$ by keeping drinks & snacks in your room!