My favorite places to eat and MUST have menu items:
Wild Mango's: coconut shrimp, jerk grouper
Blue Water: calamari, shred head sushi roll, snook
Caliente: bacon wrapped ginger rum shrimp, coconut curry shrimp
Caramba: seafood appetizer platter, lobster fajitas
BC's: sunday BBQ (generous portions, local tradition)
Rico's: combo ceviche and margaritas, lobster salad sandwich
Victoria House: best pina colada's on the island
Manuel's (across from airstrip): huevos rancheros for breakfast, tacquitos for lunch
George's: BEST breakfast, all items. Awesome bloody mary's
Estelle's: breakfast burrito
Many more, I could go on and on...