I am looking for recommendations on who to use for the overnight package to Tikal. Price range per person?

Coming from SP? or are you spending some time in Cayo and going from there?

Hey Barb! From San Pedro...

Also - along those same lines. Can anyone also comment on about how long it takes to get from Tikal to Belize City Municipal Airport? Thanks!

From the marine terminal in Bz City, you can get a bus direct to Tikal for about $25 US. Leaves at 9:30Am & 3:30 PM (if it hasn't changed). Takes about 3 1/2 hours. Taxi from the muni to the marine terminal is about 5 minutes.
Mobunny - I don't really know of anyone who does the Tikal tour as an overnight from SP now that the airlines are not flying it. You could get yourself to Bz City on a water taxi and catch this bus. Not something I can book in advance. Maybe somebody on the island who has done it can help more. Or you can get yourself to San Ignacio and easily arrange a tour from there. I could get you a driver from Bz City to SI, or you can bus it. Spend a night or 3 in SI - it's a great town! LOTS to do and see.

Clinton at Ocean Adventures Tours does the overnight tour to Tikal...they use a van from the Guatemalan border to Lake Peten and stay there for the night....Tikal the next day. Been there...done that!
www.oceanadventurestours.com