Hi Canuker...as far as the pizza price goes you have to remember that cheese is crazy expensive down here and so is the toppings thats why pizza is not a cheap meal option here.
Go to Celi's or Ali Baba's order one of the rotisserie chickens and a side will make a great meal. Waraguma I can't even eat a full burrito. Hidden Treasures great food good prices, Mickeys also very affordable and good food.
I agree with Lan if you want to drink cheap it has to be local rum and local beer. Everything else is imported and costs an arm and a leg.
Enjoy the rest of your trip!!

Okay.

Carumba's, Waramuga(sp?), Elvi's, and this place described below:
good, inexpensive (local) restaurant located a 2 minute walk N of Banyan Bay and 30 seconds S of Marina's store.

Is this last un-named place located on the right or left as you head north towards SP?

Antojitos...left side

Another question while I am thinking about it. Is it illegal to walk down the street with a Belekin or alcoholic beverage in your hand?

Yes

but balanced on top of your head is okay

Thanks Jesse for both answers. :-)

LOL. That might be tough to do after the second rum punch though...

canuker, don't know where you live, but we do not find it that expensive on the Island......imported booze is about the only thing we find much more expensive. We spend as much for a good meal here in the US (Washington State) as we do on the Island.

We are from Ontario, Canada and didn't find the prices that bad either except booze/wine and coffee!

Yes, the three necessities of life!!