many people have varied opinions, of course. i enjoyed my stay there in august. my photos are at http://ambergriscaye.com/jane/
if you want to see the place, pre-keith. as i said, the rooms werent big or special, but the staff tried hard to accommodate you, always smiling and joking. the food is very good, but pricey, and dinners are limited to 3 or 4 entrees per nite. if rendezvous is open by then, it is just a few steps up the beach and their lobster thai style was the yummiest. if JE serves paella one nite, get it! the beach view is gorgeous and abounds in sea birds. it is private and quiet. thats what i wanted, peace and tranquility. dont know of the fishing, i dont fish. the snorkeling was good, and steve at the dive shop was great. my hubby did 9 dives in 1 week with them. the sea kayaks are free and were fun too. check out my photos, and if you have any more specific questions, let me know.