Mary here, of Mary and Scott(my hubby). We do not dive,so you should take the advice of others on the board. I can't tell you how much you will love this island. The people are so wonderful and friendly, and you can go anywhere,and eat anywhere in shorts, tee shirts and sandals.Besides Papi's, we enjoyed Celi's Deli on Front Street...great meat pies,tamales,wonderful things called Garnaches(?spelling) and Mayan burritos(made with a wonderful cheese filling), very inexpensive. We would load up on Celi's goodies and go back to our room and have a feast! We also enjoyed Estel's by the Sea for breakfast,although they were a little bit more expensive, but worth it for the view...tables right out on the sand if you want! We also ate from the street vendors, something we would never have done in Mexico, but we never had a problem with any food we ate in AC. Have a wonderful vacation!
Mary and Scott