My wife and I just got back from Exotic Caye. We stayed over the holidays and had a great time. Pirate is right, the bar is right on the property. Great bar. Very friendly place. Spent a wild New Year there. Best party by far!!!!
If Pirate is the same one we met, "HI Pirate". We stayed right next door to you in room 2B.
The location of Exotic Cays is just south of the Belize Yacht Club and Resort. It is about 1/4 of a mile +- south of Ramons and just down the street from the super market for any in room "provisions". About a 15 to 20 minute walk will put you right in town to sample all of the restaurants. We ate at a different place for every meal. That is what makes this location nice. It is also across the "street" from the Green Iguana night club. Not to worry, we did not hear a sound.
If you have not been to Belize before, take the advice of other postings. Go with an open mind and you will have a great time. Remember it is a third world country. Exotic Caye was great. Ambergris Caye has the friendlest people out of any place that my wife have every traveled to. Enjoy.