Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
#505166 - 06/12/15 12:13 PM Court presses for hearing on cruise port head tax  
Joined: Oct 1999
Posts: 52,664
Marty Offline
Marty  Offline
–Last month, we told you of Government’s plan to introduce new legislation in Parliament, to confirm and validate the US$7 cruise tourism head tax retrospectively, amid a challenge to the tax regime lodged in the Supreme Court by Michael Feinstein, whose US$100 million Stake Bank project is stalled due to an impasse with investors in the Fort Street Tourism Village (FSTV.)

The planned port would provide a new offshore port for the cruise tourism sector at Stake Bank Island, a few miles from Belize City; however, the development would rival the existing port at the Fort Street Tourism Village in Belize City, which claims exclusivity under a contract with the Government of Belize, to which Feinstein was a party before he sold his interest in that investment to Royal Caribbean. Under the existing arrangement, Stake Bank would not be guaranteed a portion of the head tax.

Although Feinstein has sued the Government over the allocation of the head tax to FSTV—from which the FSTV would have earned nearly US$4 million last year—FSTV has countersued for damages, because it claims that if the head tax were to be lost, it would mean a substantial loss of revenue, although its exclusive contract with the Government does not expire until 2028.

Supreme Court Justice Courtney Abel was scheduled to hear the FSTV’s case today and tomorrow, but just as Prime Minister Dean Barrow had indicated, counsel for the Government, Nigel Hawke, sought an adjournment pending the passage of the legislation by Parliament. Senior Counsel Rodwell Williams also argued for an adjournment on the basis that he had a clashing appearance this morning in the Court of Appeal in the case of Roberta Richmond versus Belize Aquaculture Limited.

Justice Abel reluctantly granted an adjournment, but only until next Thursday, June 18, since the judge, who is strongly opposed to what he described as “a culture of adjournments in Belize that has to stop,” says that the promise of legislation to be tabled on Friday, June 26, is mere speculation and does not concern him.

After this morning’s court session, Amandala had a chance to speak with Feinstein, who told us that the promise of the legislation gives him “no sense of comfort whatsoever,” because he has not seen it.

While the Prime Minister told us in May that he had already shared a draft of the bill with Royal Caribbean and the FSTV group, Feinstein’s attorney told us today that he had not seen a copy – and neither have they been apprised of the details of the legislation in the letters which the Government has written to them.

Hawke, who declined an interview this morning when we asked him, told us that he also does not have details of the bill, since it was not drafted by the Attorney General’s Ministry.
The Prime Minister had told us that his decision to resort to legislation resulted from the fact that attempts by him to personally broker a settlement between the parties—FSTV and Feinstein—remained at an impasse, as neither party would compromise its position.

Feinstein said that thecourt will, hopefully, decide where they go from here.

Andrew Marshalleck, SC, of Barrow and Co. (the law firm of Denys Barrow, SC), told us that his client, Feinstein, had challenged a number of provisions in the FSTV’s contract with the Government of Belize, particularly questioning the Government’s authority to contract obligations of the nature that it has.

A central issue in their claim is the decision by the Government of Belize to designate the FSTV as the exclusive port for cruise passengers for the Belize District. Marshalleck said that, “Exclusive arrangements have always been of suspect validity,” because Government is essentially deciding the application of all potential future investors negatively, even before they have seen them – which, Marshalleck contends, is outside the powers of the executive.

Another central element of Feinstein’s challenge is the Government’s decision to award the bulk of the head tax (US$4 of the US$7) to the FSTV.

“We are saying that in accordance with the Constitution, only Parliament has authority to impose a tax and determine how it is to be spent, and what we have is the executive usurping legislative function – not unlike the PetroCaribe challenge; we rely pretty much on the identical financial provisions of the Constitution in that the tax must be imposed under authority of an act and can only be spent under authority of an act – neither of which exists in relation to head taxes,” Marshalleck said.

He told us that whereas the Government says it is an entirely administrative arrangement, the Feinstein claim contends that the arrangement is then entirely illegal.

Rodwell Williams, SC, of Barrow and Williams (the Prime Minister’s law firm), told Amandala that they had filed an ancillary claim in response to Feinstein’s claim, arguing that if the head tax were to be lost, it would represent a loss of revenue to his client, whose contract runs up to 2028. We asked him exactly how much his client would be seeking in damages, but he told us that he did not have the exact figure to share with us.

Prime Minister Barrow has told us that he can’t allow for the head tax arrangement to be scuttled, because FSTV will be shut down if there is no head tax—a move which would no doubt be devastating to the cruise sector.

According to Marshalleck, the FSTV’s counter-lawsuit against the Government and Feinstein would fall away if the new legislation which Government proposes to introduce later this month validates the head tax arrangement, since FSTV would not suffer any loss in head taxes. Although that might resolve FSTV’s concern, though, it does nothing for Mr. Feinstein, Marshalleck said.

Marshalleck expects that the Government’s counsels will again try to seek an adjournment from Justice Abel in June 18.

“The object of this exercise is to push things past the date when the act is tabled, so that the act can be brought back to the court in answer to the claim. Again, that sounds familiar?” Marshalleck commented.


#505524 - 06/27/15 04:52 AM Re: Court presses for hearing on cruise port head tax [Re: Marty]  
Joined: Oct 1999
Posts: 52,664
Marty Offline
Marty  Offline

Head Tax Law and the Possibilities of Case in Court

The Cruise Ship Passenger Tax and Validation Bill was also passed through all its stages today. Now, this is a bill to validate the head tax - which as you may recall is being argued in the Supreme court this very week. So how does the legislation interact with the ongoing proceedings in court? Well, it's interesting - because of the possibilities that the lawsuit raises:..

Hon. Dean Barrow, Prime Minister
"What is does, is of course, it ensures that there can be no disruption in terms of the cruise industry. If Mr. Feinstein have succeeded in getting a court adjudication that the head tax is invalid, until we could have corrected that we couldn't pay FSTV and they would no doubt close that village. So we wanted to avoid that and once this passes we'll achieve that result, but that's not the end of the case. Apart from the question of wanting to have collection of the Head Tax declared illegal as well as I understood Feinstein is also arguing that the entire contract between the Government of Belize and FSTV is illegal and that in fact we do want to see play out and quite frankly I don't want in fact appear to be looking to take on FSTV but if the court rule in favor of Mr. Feinstein, that would certainly allow us to see our way far more clearly."

Jules Vasquez
"And in fact you saw the contract that your Government signed. So if it were to fall by the way side?"

Hon. Dean Barrow, Prime Minister
"A brand new ball game. We would then feel that we could say to FSTV, listen we are going to find a way to proceed with the construction of the new facility. What's holding us back now, well a number of things but in particular from the point of view of FSTV is the contractual exclusivity. So, if the court says no, that has to go, then the options available to the Government becomes far more wide ranging."

Channel 7

Portofino Resort- Now with a new BEACH BAR!!

Click for excellent scuba lessons with Elbert Greer!

Things to do

Daily News
Daily Weather

Classified Ads
San Pedro Sun
Ambergris Today
SP Town Council
Channel 7
Channel 5
Love FM
The Reporter
Caye Caulker

TV Newscasts
Radio Stations

Click for our
Search thousands of Belizean-only websites

Event Guides
Event Calendar
Specials & Events
Things to Do
iTravel Belize
Paradise Theater

San Pedro Scoop!
Tia Chocolate
My Beautiful Belize
I-Travel Belize
Belize Adventure
Belize Hub
Romantic Travel
Bound for Belize
Conch Creative
As The Coconuts Drop
More Blogs...
Search thousands of Belizean-only websites
Chaa Creek is an award-winning luxury Belize Resort, rated as one of the worlds best Eco Lodges. We are a pioneer in adventure travel to Belize since 1981!
White Sands Dive Shop - 5 Star PADI Dive Facility - Daily diving, SCUBA instruction and Snorkeling
Caribbean Inspired All Natural Condiments & Spice Blends, Over 100 are Gluten Free!
We manage a variety of homes, apartments, condos and commercial properties here on Ambergris Caye. Our minimum lease on ALL properties is six months.
Conch Shell Inn: All rooms are right on the beach in the heart of San Pedro, so within walking distance to anything and everything!!
Lil� Alphonse has snorkel equipment to fit anyone as well as Marine Park Tickets and flotation devices to assist those not as experienced.
Coastal Xpress offers a daily scheduled ferry run to most resorts, restaurants and private piers on the island of Anbergris Caye. We also offer  private and charter water taxi service.
1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28
Cayo Espanto
Click for Cayo Espanto, and have your own private island
More Links
Click for exciting and adventurous tours of Belize with Katie Valk!
Mini Chat
Who's Online Now
7 registered members (dabunk, buktoff, 4 invisible), 34 guests, and 5 spiders.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Forum Statistics
Most Online1,262
Jun 10th, 2007 HELP! Visitor Center Goods & Services San Pedro Town Message Board Lodging Diving Fishing Things to Do History Maps Phonebook Belize Business Directory Picture of the Day

The opinions and views expressed on this board are the subjective opinions of Ambergris Caye Message Board members
and not of the Ambergris Caye Message Board its affiliates, or its employees.

Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.6.0