Ambergris Caye Caye Caulker Help! Visitor Center Businesses Picture of the Day Lodging
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
#517103 - 08/26/16 10:17 AM Leaked OAS Report Damning For Guats  
Joined: Oct 1999
Posts: 52,555
Marty Online happy
Marty  Online Happy

In last night's news, you saw Brigadier General David Jones expressing confidence that his soldiers would be vindicated in the fatal shooting of 14 year-old Guatemalan Julio Rene Alvarado Ruano.

That's the incident which sent Guatemalan President Jimmy Morales into demagogue mode calling the BDF all kinds of names, accusing them of murder, and triggering a military buildup along the Belize Guatemala border.

Well, our colleagues at KREM News managed to secure a leaked copy of the OAS report which has still not been released. The report vindicates the BDF, and exposes that the Guatemalans as trying to bamboozle that investigation by attempting to conceal evidence. That evidence clearly showed that the Belizean Joint Forces Patrol did indeed come under fire from hostile Guatemalan civilians, and they returned fire in self-defence.

So, to the report itself... It's dated, August 18, last week Thursday, and the Independent Investigating team wrote to OAS Secretary General Luis Almagro.

They then outline each and every single piece of research they went over which includes news clippings, and emails sent from the OAS officials to both Belize and Guatemala, diplomatic notes that both countries shared between themselves, letters of important public officials who all address the fatal Chiquibul shooting, past interviews that OAS officials did with the parties involved, and a host of other materials. The independent investigators also conducted their own interviews with the Belizean Law Enforcement team involved in the shooting, and members of the Guatemalan family who were injured in that shooting.

The experts also went to the site of the shooting, which was determined to be an area called "El Sapote" in the "Chiquibul" National Forest. That location is 562 meters east of the Adjacency Line, which puts it squarely in Belizean territory. There, the experts did careful studies to put together a map with all relevant forensic data.

After completing all that, they then set about to produce a timeline of the events, and they compiled all versions from the Belizeans and the Guatemalans to examine the similarities and differences.

The experts were able to determine that persons who were involved in that shooting on April 20, 2016 included Carlos Alfredo Alvarado Ramírez, age 48; his sons: 14 year-old Julio René Alvarado Ruano and 12 year-old Carlos Alberto Alvarado Ruano; Belizean FCD Rangers Benjamin Cal and Darren Harrys; and BDF Lt. Rodriguez.

After producing all that the investigators were able to establish a number of facts. For context, we reproduce their findings to ensure that you appreciate exactly what the investigators have concluded


1. The person killed was a minor: Julio Rene Alvarado Ruano (14 years old). Wounded were the father, Carlos Alfredo Alvarado Ramírez (48 years old) (left knee) and his son, Carlos Alberto Alvarado Ruano (12 years old) (left elbow).  
2. There is evidence that this was not the first time that Julio Rene Alvarado Ruano had been in Belize

3. The wounds suffered by Julio Rene Alvarado Ruano were caused, in the case of his neck, to a .22 caliber rifle, and the wounds that he has in the left shoulder and the dorsal area correspond to wounds produced by a 12 gauge shotgun….the first shots to hit Julio Rene Alvarado Ruano were to his left front shoulder area and correspond to wounds produced by a 12 gauge shotgun.  The wounds of Carlos Alfredo Alvarado Ramirez and Carlos Alberto Alvarado Ruano were produced by the 12 gauge shotgun.  The caliber 5.56 M4 carbine (which is the weapon that the BDF uses) did not produce any of the wounds.  

And this is where it gets very interesting.

The investigating team says, quote, "There is evidence that, at a minimum, five different groups visited the site of the incident (after the event).  These include visits by villagers, and a visit by the Guatemalan Army with the chairman of the village. As a result of these visits, evidence was obtained including fired cartridge cases in calibers .22 and 5.56 – by a Guatemalan villager, and a 12 gauge shot column found by Dr. Hamby.

And on the matter of the concealing of evidence, the investigators say,

"According to interview documents, the two (2).22 caliber cartridge cases that were collected at the site of the event (one by the villager and one by the Guatemalan Army), do not appear in any evidence logs. (In the interviews, it was stated that these .22 caliber cartridge cases were either given to – or collected by - the Guatemalan Army). Having these cartridge cases is desirable for further forensic examination of this incident. The Guatemalan police report mentions the 5.56 cartridge cases and also includes photographs of this evidence.  At the site, there is evidence of two branches that have holes from shots fired from where the Ramirez's family was located towards the BDF/FCD.  There were at least 31 projectiles (bullets / pellets).. This does not include any shots that may have been fired by the Ramirez's family.

So, that's what it is. The BDF soldier did not injure any of the Alvarado men. The fatal shot most likely came from the FCD rangers. There was evidence that the Alvarado men fired on the soldiers, but, that evidence was removed from the scene. Only through digging, did the investigators manage to unearth it.

Belizean law enforcement acted therefore with professionalism under extreme duress and dangerous conditions.

For context, here again are those outrageous accusations against the Belizean lawmen from those high-ranking Guatemalan officials:

Jimmy Morales – President of Guatemala
"Citizens of Guatemala, with profound sadness and with total condemnation, I communicate to our people that yesterday members of the Belize Defense force killed another Guatemalan. To our dismay, this time the victim is a 13-year-old boy. The cowardly and excessive attack was against 13 year old Julio Rene Alvarado Ruano, whose body is still in the hands of the Belizean authorities."

"During the attack his brother Carlos Alberto Alvarado 11 years old and his dad Carlos Alfredo Alvarado Ramirez, 48 years old, also sustained gunshot injuries. They were found planting pumpkin seeds in the Adjacency zone"

"I ask the Belizean authorities, what threat to your sovereignty do these two children pose? One 13 and the other of 11? This act provokes severe indignation and repudiation. I want to express my strong condemnation of this cowardly act of aggression and use of excessive force against minors on the part of the Belize Defense Force."

H. E. Manuel Roldan Barillas - Guatemalan Ambassador to Belize 
"This is an unspeakable act. It is something completely disgraceful for which Belize will have to explain the circumstances....Unfortunately, as you know, since 1999 there have been 10 killings of Guatemalans at the hands of the BDF and we view this with concern. Unfortunately, we recognize that although there may be a lack of discretion by the armed forces of Belize in contrast to that of Guatemala, a professional army, which although they have been trained for war, that would be the last resort... I see the bilateral relation with Belize damaged at this time by a completely condemnable act." End quote.

H.E. Carlos Raul Morales - Guatemalan Foreign Minister 
"We could be very angry about what occurred with the death of this child but we won't react like them. We won't go and hunt down a Belizean, like they have hunted down Guatemalan farmers before. Sorry for the strong expression but that is literally what they have done. But we will not act in the same manner."

Since then, the report has seriously undermined the integrity of the Guatemalans acting as good-faith and honourable neighbours - since their law enforcement units tried to frustrate the investigation which vindicates Belize. Add to that the undermining of the Confidence Building Measures, which Belizean officials religiously follow, and the relationship quickly begins to cause worry.

Tomorrow afternoon, the OAS will formally deliver the report, and the Foreign Minister will make a statement on it at Friday's House Meeting.

Channel 7

#517123 - 08/26/16 09:34 PM Re: Leaked OAS Report Damning For Guats [Re: Marty]  
Joined: Oct 1999
Posts: 52,555
Marty Online happy
Marty  Online Happy

Statement delivered by Honourable Wilfred Elrington, Minister of Foreign Affairs to the House of Representatives on the report of the experts who conducted the formal investigation of the incident in the Belize Administered Adjacency Zone in which the Guatemalan minor lost his life on April 20th, 2016.

Mr. Speaker,

With your kind permission, I would wish to inform the Honourable House and the citizens of Belize this morning, that yesterday Ambassador Magdalena Talamas, Special Representative of the OAS Secretary General for Belize- Guatemala Affairs, who is charged with responsibilities for the office of the OAS in the adjacency zone, has officially delivered to me a copy of the findings of the two special investigators who had been commissioned by the OAS to conduct a special independent and impartial investigation of the shooting incident which took place on the Chiquibul Forest in April last, for on transmission of same to The Belizean Authorities responsible for conducting criminal investigations in our country- namely the Belize Police Department.

With the concurrence of the Guatemalan Government, The Government of Belize had formally requested of the OAS, assistance in sourcing the experts to do the investigation. Two experts were sourced one from Mexico one from the United States of America.

The following is a summarized version of the incident and the investigation as prepared by the officials of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs.

The Government of Belize had asked H.E. Luis Almagro Lemes, Secretary General of the Organization of American States (OAS) to establish an independent investigative commission to support Belize's own national investigations of the incident that occurred on April 20, 2016 involving a Guatemalan minor, Julio René Alvarado Ruano, who was shot and killed in the Cebada area of the Chiquibul National Park in Belize. With the mandate to conduct a transparent and independent investigation, this Commission was comprised of two very senior forensic scientists, Dr. James E. Hamby (of the USA) and Dr. Patricia Rosa Linda Trujillo Mariel (of Mexico). After an extensive examination of all the data, documentation and evidence available, this Commission presented its report to Secretary General Almagro on 18th August 2016. The Secretary General delivered this report to the governments of Belize and Guatemala on Friday19th August 2016.

The Commission of independent experts was able to establish a number of facts that are critical in clarifying what actually happened around that fatal day. The main findings of the investigation are:

The incident occurred in the early nightfall - sometime between 6:15 and 7:00 pm - of 20th April 2016, in the Cebada area of the Chiquibul National Park in Belize, when the deceased, Julio Rene Alvarado Ruano, accompanied by his father, Carlos Alfredo Alvarado Ramirez, and younger brother, Carlos Alberto Alvarado Ruano, were returning home to Guatemala, having entered Belize illegally and having been conducting illegal activities in Belize, when they walked onto some elements of a Belizean patrol comprised of Belize Defence Force (BDF) and personnel from the Non-governmental Organization Friends for Conservation and Development (FCD);

The incident occurred 562 meters east of the border or Adjacency Line, i.e. well inside Belize;

AGuatemalan minor, Julio Rene Alvarado Ruano (14 years old), was killed. Injured were his father Carlos Alfredo Alvarado Ramirez (48 years old) (left knee) and his brother Carlos Alberto Alvarado Ruano (12 years old) (left elbow);

The three persons were in the regular habit of entering Belize illegally to conduct illegal activities such as hunting and farming in Belize’s protected areas of the Chiquibul. The father confirmed that he had been entering Belize for many years and that he was fully aware that he was engaging in illegal activities in Belize. Despite knowing this, he encouraged his children to accompany him and also engage in illegal activities;

The deceased, Julio Rene Alvarado, had already been detained in Belizean territory on March 2, 2016, the month before his death, by a Belizean patrol. He, along with others who escaped at the time, were engaged in illegal hunting. He had in his possession two gibnuts that had been shot and killed. Such activities are illegal in Belize’s protected areas, but considering that he was a minor, the Belizean patrol chose not to arrest him on that occasion and instead gave him a strong warning and set him free to return safely to his home in Guatemala;

The deceased received 8 shots, 2 of which entered from a front to back direction and 6 that entered from a back to front direction. The first shots to hit him were two 12-guage pellets on the front shoulder. It is likely that when he first heard shots he turned around to run, which explains how he received the first two shots from the front and then others from the back. All the shots he received were produced by bullets from a .22 caliber rifle and pellets from a 12-gauge shotgun;

The wounds received by the father, Carlos Alvarado Ramirez, and the brother Carlos Alberto Ruano were from pellets produced by 12-gauge type shotgun;

The caliber 5.56 M4 carbine used by the BDF did not produce any injury on the deceased nor any of the wounds in the father and brother of the deceased;

There is evidence that shots were fired from where the Ramirez’s family was located towards the Belizean patrol;

The scene of the incident was tampered with and valuable evidence was collected and retrieved by Guatemalan nationals before the OAS representatives or the independent experts could visit the site. This was done by villagers of San José, Las Flores, Guatemala, who in the morning after the incident entered Belize illegally and visited the scene, as well as by soldiers of the Guatemalan Army who also entered illegally into Belizean territory the day after the incident and visited the site;

The findings seem to confirm that indeed the Belizean patrol responded to shotgun fire after it had ordered the individuals to stop, and that none of the shots fired by the BDF caused any harm to the Guatemalan nationals.

The report of the investigation will be reviewed fully by our authorities for necessary action and it will serve as a crucial part of the overall investigation surrounding the incident. The report should also be useful for our authorities to review practices and procedures with a view to further improvement.

The Government of Belize continues to be concerned by Guatemalan nationals who knowingly and persistently enter Belize illegally and engage in illegal activities in our protected areas, including the carrying of firearms and other illegal weapons, and who by their actions cause tremendous destruction to wildlife, flora and fauna which threaten not only Belizean security and law enforcement personnel but also the freshwater reservoirs on which both Belizean and Guatemalan communities so much depend.

Everyone is reminded that it is an obligation of every person in our territory to respect the laws and law enforcement authorities of Belize, and that it is the Government's responsibility to ensure that this is done.

The Government of Belize wishes to express its appreciation to the Secretary General H.E. Luis Almagro Lemes for commissioning this transparent and independent investigation. Through him, we also wish to thank Dr. Patricia Rosa Linda Trujillo and Dr. James E. Hamby for their dedicated expertise and professionalism. The Government of Belize wishes also to express its thanks to the governments of the USA and Mexico for responding positively to the OAS call for independent experts.

26th August, 2016

Portofino Resort- Now with a new BEACH BAR!!

Click for excellent scuba lessons with Elbert Greer!

Things to do

Daily News
Daily Weather

Classified Ads
San Pedro Sun
Ambergris Today
SP Town Council
Channel 7
Channel 5
Love FM
The Reporter
Caye Caulker

TV Newscasts
Radio Stations

Click for our
Search thousands of Belizean-only websites

Event Guides
Event Calendar
Specials & Events
Things to Do
iTravel Belize
Paradise Theater

San Pedro Scoop!
Tia Chocolate
My Beautiful Belize
I-Travel Belize
Belize Adventure
Belize Hub
Romantic Travel
Bound for Belize
Conch Creative
As The Coconuts Drop
More Blogs...
Search thousands of Belizean-only websites
Chaa Creek is an award-winning luxury Belize Resort, rated as one of the worlds best Eco Lodges. We are a pioneer in adventure travel to Belize since 1981!
White Sands Dive Shop - 5 Star PADI Dive Facility - Daily diving, SCUBA instruction and Snorkeling
Caribbean Inspired All Natural Condiments & Spice Blends, Over 100 are Gluten Free!
We manage a variety of homes, apartments, condos and commercial properties here on Ambergris Caye. Our minimum lease on ALL properties is six months.
Conch Shell Inn: All rooms are right on the beach in the heart of San Pedro, so within walking distance to anything and everything!!
Lil� Alphonse has snorkel equipment to fit anyone as well as Marine Park Tickets and flotation devices to assist those not as experienced.
Coastal Xpress offers a daily scheduled ferry run to most resorts, restaurants and private piers on the island of Anbergris Caye. We also offer  private and charter water taxi service.
1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28
Cayo Espanto
Click for Cayo Espanto, and have your own private island
More Links
Click for exciting and adventurous tours of Belize with Katie Valk!
Mini Chat
Who's Online Now
2 registered members (Marty, ThomasCat), 39 guests, and 4 spiders.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Forum Statistics
Most Online1,262
Jun 10th, 2007 HELP! Visitor Center Goods & Services San Pedro Town Message Board Lodging Diving Fishing Things to Do History Maps Phonebook Belize Business Directory Picture of the Day

The opinions and views expressed on this board are the subjective opinions of Ambergris Caye Message Board members
and not of the Ambergris Caye Message Board its affiliates, or its employees.

Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.6.0