Yes, all the info gets crowded before the first visit. My recommendation is go south of town where it is quieter and still only a 10-15 minute walk to town and stay at a small resort with less people and noise. Top personal preference is Caribbean Villas Hotel: only 10 rooms and suites on 2 acres of land with long-time staff who are very guests focused, bird sanctuary, hot tubs, free bikes, hammocks, pier with swimming and snorkeling area. Their rooms and 1 bedroom suites are very reasonable, especially in the summer; ask for 10% off if you book directly. The resort does not accept commissions from guides or tour companies, so you get objective recommendations and in some cases cheaper prices. They have a dive arrangement with Amigos del Mar dive shop. Owners live on the property and are involved in the daily operation. They have a web site with link under "Lodging" above. No matter where you stay, I think you will have a great time and you can visit all the places you considered as you tour the island and be set for your next trip. Happy times there and Happy New Year...