Calm Caye Villa is the one to book. BB is very nice, but compared to Calm CAye Villa, it can't compete. Calm Caye is a nice big 3 br, 4 bath house - decorated by artists and filled with all the goodies you could imagine ...... your own kayak, stereo, satellite tv - the kitchen even has an ice-cream maker.
BB has a narrow beach, shared with lots of other guests ...... Calm Caye has a one-acre site with a very broad beach - there are only 5 accommodations sharing the pool, the big beach, gardens ......... it's a winner. Laginape provisioning will deliver cases of beer/ fine imported wines and virtually every other kind of food-stuff you might wish prior to your arrival. Walking distance to great restaurants, and just a short paddle in your own kayak out to the reef where you can snorkel on your own (no need to wait for a throng of tourists to fill a boat). It's great - book it.