We have been staying at Mata Rocks for ten years. Obviously we think very highly of it. It is a small complex with nice rooms and some Jr. Suites.
The Squirels Nest bar is located about 50 feet from the hotel and is a great place to hang out and get a nice refreshing drink or ice cold beer.
The owners, Terry and Liz, a great people and the have a wonderful staff working for them. If you want a laid back, clean, comfortable and safe place to hang your hat, I personally don't think you can do any better.
Whereever you decide on you will simply love the island, have great trip and enjoy!