I have been looking for rental for 2 months next winter. The one that seems the most promising is Coral Reef Villas. They quoted me $600mn for a 1 bedroom and $900 for a 2BR. You have use of Banyon Bay facilities, which are a 3 minute walk. Looked good to me but I have not seen it with my own eyes.
Bannana Beach quoted me $2,200 for a 1 br suite, I would asume it is small. And that price was for winter-could be consideraly less for summer.
I have been turned down alot because I want to come in season. You will probably do better. If I get anymore replys that look good I'll pass them on. My husband and I will be down May 8 to 15. Would be nice to meet you.