we have never been to Caye Caulker. We like quiet places - if there is something I can't stand is a constant "disco-boom" at night... For peace and quiet, is it better to stay more direction airstrip (I assume no planes during nights...) or more direction the Split ? I have heard of the Sunset Disco and I&I Reggae Bar but I don't know where they are and how loud they are.
We are going in May - don't know if the season makes a difference for the disco...

Thank you for anything that might help us !