Hi Windyw and Sharyn,
My husband and I just got back from 10 days in San Pedro, and we enjoyed it very much - but we spent one afternoon on Caye Caulker and my husband fell in love! next year we are going back and we're thinking of splitting our time between the two islands, and we're bringing our 13 year old son. He's easy to please so far so I don't predict that being a problem (a lot can change in a year for a teenager) but any suggestions on 2 bedroom accomodations would be greatly appreciated! Also any other tips on Caye Caulker.. We love being on the ocean, on the beach - we're not big night clubbers or shoppers, just want to be together and relax and play as a family.