I always thought you srota viewed Fatal Attraction as a love story.
I wasn't allowed to go to movies growing up but I read Jaws when I was in high school. It scared me so bad I didn't want to go in the swimming pool - I knew that didn't make sense, but that book was really frightening!
Also read Little Girl Who Lives Down the Lane - saw the movie later, there was a lot more sexual content in the book
I remember a movie on TV from when I was pretty young - Picture Mommy Dead - the only movie I can remember ever giving me nightmares