I think that there may be some confusion here, as there are 2 "Crawl Cayes" in Belize. One Crawl Caye is out on Lighthouse Reef adjacent to Mauger Caye and would be very vulnerable to weather as noted by Captain Watson. But there's another Crawl Cay located off Placencia in the South Water Caye Marine Reserve. I believe that it is that one that NCL is considering?
//ambergriscaye.com/maps/art/Belize_Dive_Mapsm.jpg