We had dinner at Capricorn and looked into one of the three cabanas they have ...really nice, but pretty basic...a couple that was staying there (the only ones at the time) said it was really quiet during the day and they had the whole beach and outdoor bar to themselves until the dinner crowd arrived..it's very pretty at night w/ white lights on the trees, music from the restaurant, but you would need a water taxi to go into town unless you are extremely energetic!! I looked at Xanadu also and I liked the beach area in front because it had lounge chairs under palm trees and a nice beachfront pool...I didn't look into the units, but some of them were right on the beach w/ balconies or porches w/ great views of the water....we made the walk into town almost daily and also had a golf cart and we stayed even farther south at Banana beach.