We were in the same boat as you too, goody and I both bailed at the same time after receiving the letter from II. I was very nervous about staying that far from town ONLY because of my daughter.. I would have had to spend a fortune for water taxis and would have done a lot of worrying about her because the drinking age is 18, and I know she would have wanted to be in town partying! If it would have been just my husband and myself, we would have enjoyed the peace and quiet and have only read good things about the scuba shop there (BAD). I have seen some pictures of the place and it looks beautiful!!! Remote has it's benefits, but it's a downfall when transportation and partying are an issue! We do plan on going and checking it out soon... 17 more days! I really don't think you can go wrong wherever you stay on AC, it all depends on what you want out of it.