thanks klcman and chattykathy...unfortunately they never did respond but we have had fantastic responses from our other choices. Now we just have to decide between the three. There is paradise villas, mata rocks and banana beach. They are so different and all have an appeal although we are tempted by the privacy that paradise villas offer but we like the deal that mata rocks offer with two free snorkelling trips. But if anyone has any views or suggestions on this, I would more than welcome them.