You will have a good time at Captain Morgan's. Being on your honeymoon I can forsee "town" as a one day/one evening option.
Nice secluded beaches and less folks driving/walking around. Nice for evening walks on the beach and stargazing.
Capricorn is next door and awesome for romantic dinners.
All the cabanas at Captain Morgan's are on a large white sand beach, not really good for swiming though.
Victoria House is a definite step up from Captain Morgan's. Awesome location, terry cloth robes and slippers, nicer cabanas for sure. All cabanas are on the beach.
Also very nice beaches and uncongested as with down town locations.
Min. 45 minute walk to town, I walk it daily.
Very classy, amazing restaurant at VH.