I didn't get the poll thing, either!
I stayed at the Blue Tang in '03 and loved everything about it. The pool is small but not crowded....good selection of chairs around it, too! Suite 15 was very nice and the staff was most helpful before and during our stay. I really liked the British Colonial look of it, too. The beach in front is nicer than many, but all of the swimming that I saw took place at the end of the Paradise Villas dock. The Blue Tang staff kept the beach clear of washed up seagrass, but there is a lot of it growing in the water. We like having a kitchen and being close to town. There are two grocery stores 5 minutes away and a bakery a couple of blocks north. The continental breakfast was also a treat each morning.
We would have stayed there on our return visit, but we were late with our planning and they didn't have 5 available suites for our group. (We stayed at Nellie Gomez's Paradise Villas next door and were happy there, too, even though we were in a garden view villa!)
Wednesday nights at Wet Willy's didn't bother us at either place. We sat outside by the pool listening to the music and laughter in the distance and remembering our younger days. I wish we had spent some of them in San Pedro!