Thanks for the input and suggestions. I think BC's might be a little casual and I think we've decided against Caramba.
As for the Lady Sharon dinner cruise, what time does the sun set and what time do you think we'd have to set up the cruise to start at to be back before dark? I think this might have to start too early and not allow people to take any day trips to the mainland or diving/snorkeling or anything. Don't those typically return a little before sunset?