Restating my hasty posting from before.
A group of us stayed at The O'Farrell House last year and loved it. We want to come back but it is not available. We do not want to stay north of the bridge. Suggestions would be appreciated. BTW - not interested in package deal - we have our tour guide. (Everette & Enes Anderson from Belize Diving Adventures are amazing!)
We are 12-14 people, we love to have fun and enjoy our vacation, but never at the expense of the people's house we are renting. We have been doing this for several years and are always invited back to where we stayed. I am sure that the OFarrells would vouche for us, if they are still on the island.
Please feel free to ask me any questions you may have, or suggest anything you feel might be helpful.