Oyyyy... and I want to go back and stay/live in Belize forever and I thought you two were right there as well! (?)
O.K., check out (if you haven’t already) www.konaweb.com
as they have a great group of folks there and will answer all questions you pose to them honestly.
Also, I would suggest you purchase and peruse the book "Hawaii The Big Island Revealed" It's a really great book and tells secrets that locals don't want ya to know. All of these books "revealed" are VERY good about the Islands! The problem is lately, that locals are removing the mile markers (as the book is set up this way) so tourists can't find the special spots they are looking for.... sooooo… set your odometer when you are “in search of" dude!
Anywho, we LOVE Huggo's and always eat at Kona Inn because I want to, but there are many other places which are grand! NOTHING like BC's is there as far as I know and we have gone there on vaca a few times prior to moving and several times since we have arrived. I've asked and asked and searched and searched Robert but nadda. Not on Maui, Kaua'i, Lana'i, Moloka'i or O'ahu either. Some very cool places on the Islands, but none compare to the “ambiance” of B'C's.
Where are you staying? Dan is over there often and if I have nothing going on Maggie and I sometimes join him. If you and Loie want to do lunch, let me know. OH... you can do Maui for a day trip too and we‘ll haul ya around this Island!