Caye Caulker Lot with House - North of the Split- 45'x100' beachfront lot, facing reef. Fresh water well. 14x20 wood house, braced, interior unfinished, built in 1999. No septic installed. Mangroves trimmed, not removed. $80,000 USD - Cash or terms - Email inquiries to email@example.com
Not sure what to tell you. You need to look at how much money you have actually tied up in the property. I would look at what some of the south Caye is selling for with power etc. And base you number 10-20% lower. Just my thoughts.
The north Caye is nice and quiet...but has issues because it has limited access FWIW.