Hi. Maybe you should consider staying on Caye Caulker and taking one of the day trips (by boat) over to San Pedro, Ambergris Caye, to check it out. It's bigger, with more tourists, night life, etc. Not that there isn't night life on CC, it's just smaller, quieter, and more laid back. Depends on what you and your wife prefer. Personally, I'd take CC anyday. Check them both out. Have a great honeymoon.