You might look at our Fun, Free & Easy Guide to Ambergris Caye which is on our Web edition at http://www.turq.com/belizefirst/
(just scroll down the main home page until you come to it). It rates most hotels on the island on a one-to-five-star basis and reviews them candidly. We accept no advertising in either our Web or print editions, so the information is pretty straight.
Our new Belize First Guide to Mainland Belize (which is not on our Web edition, however) rates hotels on the mainland using the one-to-five-star system, with detailed reviews.
Editor & Publisher
Belize First Magazine