I second the opinion of KYJeff. Four of us stayed on the first floor last July. At the time, the upstairs unit was being updated, so the bottom floor might also be renovated by now. It is a great value, and if you are still looking for 5 bedrooms, it would be great. With the 2 separate units, you could have some privacy if the group didn't want to spend every waking minute together, but also be very close to each other when you wanted to get together. Phil is super, as is the Tides, which is only about 3 doors down, so the walk to the pool is nothing. It is close enough to town that you can walk but far enough away that you escape the noise.