Anybody stayed at this house just north of the cut, managed by Caye Management? I think it used to have a different name, but I don't remember it now, and so I couldn't do a "search" function. We're thinking of staying here this winter.
It used to be called Casa Teresita. It's been a while since I've been in there but it was quite nice when I was. It's in the Tres Cocos area about a 10 minute walk north of the cut (although I would recommend a golf cart for your stay.)