Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Joined: May 2000
Posts: 7,051
OP Offline
when you read a story like this it makes me pause and reflect on my life, the lives of my family, friends and of course the wonderful visitors we have in Belize.

This story drives home the absolutely amazing heroic efforts that the Amigos crew went through when their boat caught on fire and sunk.

And it reinforces my view that cattle boats are unsafe and have no place in our home town. Yeah, we all pay extra to enjoy our tours, but it is a rare event when the head count is wrong and you don't get to know the names and faces of everybody that is on your tour with you.

Cancun cruise ends in tragedy for Grand Prairie teens

By John AustinStar-Telegram Staff Writer[/align


# A post-graduation trip that promised fun in the sun turned into disaster Saturday for a group of 2008 South Grand Prairie High School graduates when their boat foundered in the waters off Cancun, leaving one of them gravely injured.
Parents of some of the teens estimated the number of Grand Prairie students at six to eight. The tourist boat with about 120 aboard partially sank, stern down, under clear skies about 1 p.m. local time and was towed ashore. It was on a snorkeling cruise with no destination, a representative of the company that arranged the trip said Monday.
Quintana Roo state police Chief Luis Felipe Ortiz said Lisa Tam Chung, one of the graduates, suffered heart and lung failure after nearly drowning when the catamaran she was on sank between Cancun and Isla Mujeres. Ortiz said she has been declared brain dead and was being kept alive Monday by a respirator, The Associated Press reported.
Fernando Contreras, an emergency staff member of Hospital Galenia in Cancun, told the Star-Telegram on Monday in a telephone interview that Chung had been admitted but would not release her condition.
John Cosme, 18, a member of the South Grand Prairie party, said he was on the upper deck of the two-level boat. Cosme said in a telephone interview from Mexico on Monday that crew members did not wait for passengers to get into life jackets before beginning to leave the vessel themselves.
Jay Wiggs said his son, Carson, 18, of Grand Prairie, told him that the crew left passengers -- perhaps 100 -- to fend for themselves.
"The crew basically said, 'Here's the life vest,' " Jay Wiggs said his son told him. "Next thing you know, the crew just took off."
Other South Grand Prairie graduates on the boat included Loren Dailey and Kyle Felts.
Cosme, Dailey and Wiggs returned home late Monday.
Cosme and Wiggs said that when the boat started taking on water, crew members threw snorkeling gear into the water and then left the boat, and several parents and students began handing out life jackets.
Cosme said that Dailey and Chung went into the water and were holding onto a rope tied between the foundering tourist boat and a rescue vessel. When the rope straightened and lifted the two girls halfway out of the water, they let go, Cosme said.
Another boat came over the top of the two girls, Cosme said, and he jumped in to help them. Cosme said he saw a man in blue trunks pull Dailey into a rescue boat, but he lost sight of Chung. He did not see her again until she was on shore and being attended by medical personnel.
Dailey suffered a bump to the head, Cosme said.
Dailey and Cosme later went to the hospital to check on their friend's condition and were told she was stable. They learned on Sunday, when Chung's mother and aunt arrived at the hospital, that the teen was brain dead, Cosme said.
Police say they are investigating whether the boat was overloaded, AP reported.
Ricardo Portugal Zubiata, a spokesman for the Red Cross in Cancun, said his agency treated people for injuries after they made land.
Workers treated five people for panic attacks, two who had fractured bones and Chung. Zubiata added that he wasn't aware of Chung's current condition.
Danh Thikim Chung, who was in Cancun, said her 18-year-old daughter was on summer break, and was going on a snorkeling trip on the boat named Sea Star, according to the Associated Press.
Wiggs said his son, Carson, thought the boat hit something. He said Carson told him, "It started taking on water and started sinking."
Late Monday, Carson Wiggs said, "It felt like we had run aground. The front of the boat was stuck but the back was moving."
Another parent, Ollie Dailey, said his daughter went into the sea with Chung after the vessel began taking on water.
"Our daughter called us and informed us that she had been involved in an accident... . It wasn't a school-sponsored trip," Dailey said. "We just know that they were involved in a boating accident."
Dailey said, "We're getting very limited information. There's a serious nature to the accident.
"They had life jackets on but they had to jump into the water," Dailey said. "They were trapped underwater. There's a student they're waiting to transport her back to the United States."
Dailey said a trust fund may be established for Chung. Her high school annual lists Chung as a three-time class favorite, a National Honor Society member and yearbook staffer.
She planned to enroll in Baylor University's honors program in the fall with a major in psychology and a minor in political science, according to her Facebook page.
Word of Chung's condition spread quickly.
"Honey bun i am praying for you," wrote classmate Marhiah Castorena on Chung's Facebook page. Other people also left messages on the page.
Dailey is listed as a 2008 cum laude South Grand Prairie graduate. Chung was also listed on the high school commencement announcement as a cum laude graduate.
Dailey said the group's trip was arranged through GradCity, headquartered in Peabody, Mass. The company's Web site advertises "... a graduation gift that you'll never forget."
GradCity has been in business since 1987 and books trips for about 50,000 annually, according to Jason Chute, operations director for the company.
Chute said the six-month-old, 75-foot boat had a capacity of 250 and was carrying about 120 when it went down.
The Sea Star is registered to a company named Aquatic Services of the Caribbean, Chute said. It carried a crew of five, plus a GradCity staff member. Chute countered the notion that the crew abandoned the passengers.
"The crew members who were reported leaving the boat went to get help," on shore, which was about 200 yards away, Chute said. "The response was very quick."
Pat Dailey has talked to her daughter several times since the accident.
"They told them to jump off the boat," she said. "She was one of the ones who was trapped.
"She said she felt like she had stopped breathing," Pat Dailey said. "She thought she had died. "She said the crew pretty much abandoned them. I can imagine the fear."
Dailey suffered a bump on the head, Cosme said. Pat Dailey said her daughter doesn't recall details of her rescue. "She just remembers that there was some guy in blue trunks," she said.
Staff writers Gary Hardee, Sally Claunch, and Constanza Morales contributed to this report.
[email protected]
JONN AUSTIN, 817-548-5418

footnote: Lisa Chung has now passed away.

Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 820
Very sad...
More info and photos here.

Joined: Nov 2000
Posts: 6,251
Thanks for sharing.

Very sad.

So far as I can tell, Amigo's catastrophic accident and AquaDives' grounding of their big boat some months later had the same cause - the ferrule at the end of a high-pressure oil hose parting company with its end fitting. Both almost new items, both genuine Caterpiller. Makes you wonder what quality control is applied to these things.

Just think what would have been the outcome had Amigo's boat foundered in the open sea, rather than inside Lighthouse Atoll.

Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 4,001
If the crew left the group !!! Think the crew of this tour boat should be hanged... If the word crew is crew not a 16 old kid working part time with no training.But will we ever know the truth?? it is mexcio.But a real freakin shame some young kid dies for nothing......

Last edited by captjeff; 06/12/08 08:57 AM.

Living The Dream Every Day!
Joined: Oct 2007
Posts: 3,281
Tragic and I bet you are right captjeff.

"Hold on Tight To Your Dreams" ELO

Link Copied to Clipboard
2 3 4 5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15
16 17 18 19 20 21 22
23 24 25 26 27 28 29
Cayo Espanto
Click for Cayo Espanto, and have your own private island
More Links
Click for exciting and adventurous tours of Belize with Katie Valk!
Who's Online Now
0 members (), 92 guests, and 0 robots.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Forum Statistics
Most Online7,413
Nov 7th, 2021 HELP! Visitor Center Goods & Services San Pedro Town Message Board Lodging Diving Fishing Things to Do History Maps Phonebook Belize Business Directory Picture of the Day

The opinions and views expressed on this board are the subjective opinions of Ambergris Caye Message Board members
and not of the Ambergris Caye Message Board its affiliates, or its employees.

Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.5