Well, they are both(Hustler's & Amigos Del Mar) almost directly in front of the hotel. If you want to get to the main drag or the Island Grocery, it's a 5 minute walk down the beach in either direction; food, bars discos, etc...and a short stagger home.
Just a suggestion, and only one man's opinion: I'd stay away from Aqua Dives, if they still exist. No need to regale you with colorful stories, but I'm a stickler for detail when I dive...'nuff said!
Have a blast!