Having never been to A/C in these months, my question is, which of these two are the nicest with regards to weather? My brother in law is going to go to A/c for their honeymoon.

Oct and Nov can get very wet due to rainy season on the Island, its also the tail end of hurricane season which seams to be the worst part of the season, you just never know...

We've been four times in November (the last four years) and the weather has been great . . . a few short spells of rain, but nothing you wouldn't expect in the tropics.

November over October, hands down.

Thanks all.

I was married in San Pedro October 22, 2005 during Hurricane Wilma. Was an amazing trip. Couldn't snorkel or anything like that, but honestly, I wouldn't have changed it one bit. There were so few people on the island as many had evacuated, that we kind of had the place to ourselves and we had a great camaraderie with those locals who stayed behind as well.

I have no problems booking an October trip and in fact, I'm going back for my anniversary this year.