I just confirmed to go to Banyan Bay instead of Mata Chica, JE, Vic House etc... Based upon what I have read on the board I think I made the right choice. We are going to have 2 nights at Cpt Morgans, 2 Nights at Cayo Espanto (nuts but you only live once) and 6 nights at Banyan Bay - I figure we have covered all the bases. We will book guides through Tanisha Tours - I am hoping this was the right choice... cannot really screw up too bad - no matter where you sleep you still in paradise... right???