When our group went in jan we took a bunch of kids clothes from infants on up.Went to a local used clothing store and stocked up..We took them to the backside and passed them out..It was a fun to see kids on the street wearing "our" new threads..Small toys are also a hit just bring those that dont require batterys..
We like to bring pretty hair things for the girls, crayons, colored paper, rubber bugs and candy & gum for the kids. We also bring line and hooks for the fishermen. We bring all kinds of flashlights for everyone. Belize it!
Mcdonalds Happy Meal toys, etc. work very well, too. Every household has a bunch of these lying around or your neighbors do. We have people around town collect them for us and never run out anymore. Easy to pack a lot of them, too.