I think the beach house would be perfect for you and your wife and maybe an other couple, but if you have some young teens going with you, I would stay a little closer to town. The kids may get bored with "remote". We took our young teen boys last summer in June. They were 12 and 15 at the time. The perfect age to travel with. They were a lot of fun and a joy. (Didn't even fight
) The Caye was so safe, we let them go along the beach to town and explore. There are bicycles to rent and many other things for them to do. They shopped for "treasures and souveniers", went for ice cream or hit the bakery, watched the wind surfers. They had a great time. Not to mention that kids their age were welcomed in the clubs and restaurants at night and they thouroughly enjoyed the music!! (We were with them at night) They made friends with some of the local kids, they swam off the dock with them, and someone was always waving to them when we rode our golfcart through town. I think the kids would enjoy the socializing.