You girls need to consider a few things . . .like each others wants, needs and desires, not to mention your budget. Do you want to spend all your time sunbathing on a quiet beach? Do you want to spend all your time hanging by a beautiful pool? Do you want to be dancing all night and be able to stagger home, each of you as individuals or in a group? Do you want to scuba dive every day? Do you all need to be in the same quarters? Even if not, check out The Palms. It's in town, it's next to the best beach "in town", etc. etc. etc.
Check this out: