Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Gov’t loses landmark land case twice #420129
10/28/11 08:23 AM
10/28/11 08:23 AM
Joined: Oct 1999
Posts: 83,498
oregon, spr
Marty Offline OP

Marty  Offline OP

Gov’t loses landmark land case twice

Before the battle over the amendment to the constitution, there was always debate on private property and property rights. On January twelfth, 2010, a Benque Viejo Del Carmen resident was watching television when he heard Minister of Economic Development, Erwin Contreras say that his property would be acquired and given to the Mount Carmel High School even though the church-run school already owned undeveloped land. Little did he know that the acquisition notice had already been published in the government gazette. But instead of accepting defeat, Samuel Bruce applied to the Supreme Court for judicial review to stop the government’s acquisition of his land. He recently won that case. It was a landmark ruling in his favor that came during a time when phrases such as Public use, private property, and proper compensation were not yet household sayings that introduced conversations of the ninth amendment. But the Attorney General’s Ministry and the Ministry of Natural Resources appealed the case. At approximately seven p.m. on Tuesday night, before Dennis Morrison, Douglas Mendes and Duke Pollard, Bruce’s attorney Said Musa set precedence in winning a case that other property owners will be citing when any government grabs their property.

“They had eight big lots, and one of the judges pointed out in the Appeal’s Case yesterday, why is it that they had this land since 2002, no school was built. And then conveniently just when this acquisition is taking place now, government writes to the church to cancel the lease. The same government of Belize had given these lots to the church to build the school. Now they cancel that lead, they got the poor pastor to renounce any rights over those eight lots simply because they wanted to get hold of Mr. Bruce’s land. Then chief justice, Conteh, having heard all the evidence—Mister Bruce’s side as well as the government’s side, the lands commissioner, everyone else testify—the Chief Justice ruled that this acquisition was totally illegal—totally in violation of the constitution. Section 17 of the constitution clearly spells out what the law is about taking away people’s property. And this law is saying no property of any description shall be compulsorily taken possession of and no interest in or right over property of any description shall be compulsorily acquired except by under a law that describes the principles and so on and which reasonable compensation is to be determined and given within a reasonable time. And it allows provides for the right of access to court for the purpose of determining whether the taking of possession or acquisition was duly carried out for a public purpose in accordance with the law. What the Chief Justice found was that it wasn’t really a public purpose. It was really confiscating Mr. Bruce’s land with denial of any discussion of compensation. They arranged for workmen to go into his landand start chopping down trees and virtually asserting ownership by the government without any regard to his rights. And as the Chief Justice at the time pointed out, whenever you are invading people’s property and purporting to take it away by force, by compulsory acquisition; the government has an obligation to first of all hear from the land owner what are your concerns and rights because the law provides for it. The land acquisition public purposes act says you must engage and enter into negotiations to purchase the land before you talk about acquiring it this way. I am giving you all this background because I think it’s important. This is a landmark case that I believe will provide comfort to Belizeans—local as well as foreign investors—that in our law, our constitution, you can’t just give away taking people’s property just like that. They must do things in a rational and reasonable way and whosoever’s property is being acquire—if properly done—must be able to secure prompt and adequate compensation in a reasonable time. That is the law. Now it is important for many reasons because this case was also cited even before the Court of Appeal heard it yesterday. The Bruce case was cited in the very same British Caribbean Bank case and the Dean Boyce case against the Attorney General and Telemedia when the first acquisition took place. And in that very case, the Court of Appeal found that the total acquisition, there was no public purpose really because they did not satisfy the law on what was a public purpose. Similarly in this case, even though on the face of it, it looks very respectable that the government want to take this land in order to help this church to build an infant school and so on, the fact of the matter is there were so many things done in the Bruce case which suggest it wasn’t done properly.”

Channel 5

Re: Gov’t loses landmark land case twice [Re: Marty] #420131
10/28/11 08:27 AM
10/28/11 08:27 AM
Joined: Oct 1999
Posts: 83,498
oregon, spr
Marty Offline OP

Marty  Offline OP

Benque resident/taxpayer comments on Appeals Court win

The man at the center of the land case, Sam Bruce, says it was a surreal experience because he had done charity and community based work for the past two decades in Benque Viejo. He says he couldn’t believe that a hard working taxpayer, who used his own capital to develop his land for community use, would be compensated by a government willing to use strong-arm tactics to deprive him of his property.

Sam Bruce, Won Appeals Court Ruling against A.G. Ministry

“When I heard they were taking my land and I won and they appealed it, I was in disbelief because here we have a community project to promote entrepreneurships, to work hand in hand with the community policing program—I’m the own fort captain, I’m a special constable—I am the chairman of Benque chamber of commerce. So my whole goal is to promote and create positive things for the town. And even the town council in their magazine, they promote my projects. Here they are actually promoting the park because they know this is a good thing. So I was in total disbelief of why this was happening. I couldn’t understand it. Here they want to take away my land when it has already been proven that the Mount Carmel has an abundance of land.”

Jose Sanchez

Sam Bruce

“How do you feel now knowing that not only did you win, but it’s a landmark case—it’s probably going to be looked at for other land owners who may have lost land to any governments to come?”

Sam Bruce

“For me this is one of the main incentives to pursue the case because Mr. Musa explained the importance of the case and that how this could affect persons in the future generations to come. And it was so important to pursue it to protect those rights of all property owners for now and in the future.”

Bruce is involved in numerous community projects and is currently constructing a pool and a park in Benque Viejo.

Channel 5

Portofino Resort- Now with a new BEACH BAR!!
Click for excellent scuba lessons with Elbert Greer!
Chaa Creek is an award-winning luxury Belize Resort, rated as one of the worlds best Eco Lodges. We are a pioneer in adventure travel to Belize since 1981!
Maruba Beach Klub and Spa is the premiere Secret Beach spa and restaurant located on the crystal blue waters of the Caribbean Sea at the center of Secret Beach, Belize
First Class Accommodations for the Budget Traveler
First Class Accommodations for the Budget Traveler

Things to do
Specials & Events
SPTB Calendar of Events

Daily News
Daily Weather

Classified Ads
San Pedro Sun
Ambergris Today
SP Town Council
Channel 7
Channel 5
Love FM
The Reporter
TV Newscasts
Radio Stations

Click for our
Search thousands of Belizean-only websites
To Get Your Questions Answered

Event Guides
Event Calendar
Specials & Events
Things to Do
Cayo Event Calendar

San Pedro Scoop!
Tia Chocolate
My Beautiful Belize
I-Travel Belize
Belize Adventure
Belize Hub
Romantic Travel
Belize Happy Adventures
Conch Creative
Caribbean Culture & Lifestyle
More Blogs...
Search thousands of Belizean-only websites
White Sands Dive Shop - 5 Star PADI Dive Facility - Daily diving, SCUBA instruction and Snorkeling
Caribbean Inspired All Natural Condiments & Spice Blends, Over 100 are Gluten Free!
Click for the Thrifty Dollar Golf Club Rental website!
Click for Ian Anderson's Caves Branch, Welcome to a World of Adventure
Lil Alphonse has snorkel equipment to fit anyone as well as Marine Park Tickets and flotation devices to assist those not as experienced.
Coastal Xpress offers a daily scheduled ferry run to most resorts, restaurants and private piers on the island of Anbergris Caye. We also offer  private and charter water taxi service.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30 31
Cayo Espanto
Click for Cayo Espanto, and have your own private island
More Links
Click for exciting and adventurous tours of Belize with Katie Valk!
ShoutChat Box
Who's Online Now
0 registered members (), 84 guests, and 0 spiders.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Forum Statistics
Most Online7,413
Nov 7th, 2021 HELP! Visitor Center Goods & Services San Pedro Town Message Board Lodging Diving Fishing Things to Do History Maps Phonebook Belize Business Directory Picture of the Day

The opinions and views expressed on this board are the subjective opinions of Ambergris Caye Message Board members
and not of the Ambergris Caye Message Board its affiliates, or its employees.

Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.1