suggestions please...
I will be returning to SP in March or April for my 5th trip

and bringing 2 newbies along. In the past, I traveled with close friends (same gender) or with family or alone. I have stayed at Paradise Villas, Banana Beach and Exotic Caye in the past.
This time, it will be with another female and a male and we're all single and want private rooms. I don't find many suites with 3 rooms that aren't quite pricey. So I'm thinking a house rental would be better? Near town preferably. Anything between $200 - $300 US per night? Ideas?