If you mean Trade Winds/ Paradise Villas then that is a great starter place to visit the island. You are in town so don't need to rent a vehicle except to go exploring. It is walking distance to dive shops, gift shops, restaurants, bars etc. You will meet a ton of local folks going about their daily business, kids going to school etc. The fresh bakery is only a few blocks stroll away.
Banana Beach is a neat resort too - it is about a mile and half out of town so it becomes more necessary to have a golf cart or taxi. There are also nearby stores, restaurants etc.
It is tough to compare resorts since everyone is so unique here.
Why not split your time between the resorts?