I also just returned from my honeymoon in mid August (left 2 days before the storm hit)
and also wanted a 'tropical looking' type of resort (actually, my wife was more set on it.) We looked all over the websites, and asked a lot of questions here, and decided on Ramon's...very similar atmosphere to Captain Morgan's (visually), but right in town...actually, about 25 yds. south of town. We walked everywhere, were never at the mercy of the water taxi, and loved it. Ramon's was quiet, and the staff were excellent in getting whatever we needed. I don't know if I would stay there again due to the prices, but they are pretty similar to Captain Morgan's from what I've heard...maybe cheaper. If you are looking for scenery in a resort, it's beautiful...if you want seclusion and to be away from everyone else...north of the cut is a good bet.