We got married and stayed at Cayo Espanto. It was great, romantic, quiet, and the service was beautiful.
It was off the island, so whenever we went to SP, we took a ferry, but it was perfect for us, because we both wanted a quiet honeymoon.
It was also very expensive, but it was a gift, so...Hey! Whatever. If we'd have paid, we may have gotten married in Vegas!
Turnbun is right - make your hotel arrangements, and let Iraida take care of everything! Because believe me, she can put on a wedding better than you imagined!
Here is a link to our pix: www.KayScott.com/Winslow