Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Long-Pending, Major Maya Judgment Handed Down #469017
07/26/13 05:04 AM
07/26/13 05:04 AM
Joined: Oct 1999
Posts: 80,387
oregon, spr
Marty Offline OP

Marty  Offline OP
For the past two days we’ve been telling you about the lawsuit that SATIIM has taken out against US Capital Energy and the Government of Belize. To a large extent, it is based on the judgments coming out of the Supreme Court in 2007 and 2010, when Chief Justice Abdulai Conteh found that the Mayans in 33 villages of Southern Belize have customary land rights over their ancestral lands. That judgment was vigorously appealed by the Barrow Administration in 2011 at the court of appeal. Two years have passed and no judgment was handed down. But yesterday, quite unexpectedly, just as new matters were about to overtake it, the Court of Appeal announced that it was ready with its judgment.

Clocking in at 198 pages, it’s one of the longest we’ve ever come across, and, who wins, who loses? Well, the experts say it’s what might be called “cocks” – in a game of “jacks,” there’s no clear winner and no clear loser.

So, the members of the Mayan community who came to court today listened intently after the session to a quick interpretation by their legal team.

Afterwards, they exited the court, and we asked their lead attorney to give a brief explanation of decision, accepting the limitation that they couldn’t possibly had digested 198 pages, and 66 thousand words in only a few minutes.

Here’s how attorney Antoinette Moore explained it:

Antoinette Moore - Attorney for the Maya Leaders Alliance
"The first thing I have to say is that the decision is 198 pages so obviously having just gotten it in my hands, I have yet the time to read it through - digest it, really what it means fully. I have no idea of the reasoning behind the decision - only what the decision is and so I can tell you that to the degree that I have read but I can't tell you much more than that. I believe next week I can tell you that. Certainly what was said in court was that grounds 1 and 2 - which I will explain - we were successful on (‘we’ being the Maya community). We were not successful on grounds 3, 4 & 5 - putting it the other way - the government who brought the appeal, because they lost at the Supreme Court - was unsuccessful in grounds 1 and 2. Which is essentially are the grounds that affirm indigenous land rights and land tenure by the Maya community in Southern Belize and that is the essential part of the case really and so the Maya Villages were successful in that and the Government was unsuccessful in that. Obviously we're very pleased about that outcome. The remainder of the judgment is the practical part that comes after acknowledging and affirming those land rights - what should happen? The then Chief Justice Conteh had ordered that the government implement a titling or some type of process to document the land rights, just as people have titles to their land - the Maya people have no form of title to document the ownership of the land. So when Chief Justice Conteh ordered that the government some type of administrative process - the majority of this court is saying that the government has no duty to do that. The other practical aspect of the case after affirming the land rights was the then Chief Justice ordering the government of Belize from taking any action or allowing any third party from taking any action that would impair the enjoyment or the use of the Maya people's land. Now this court -the majority decision has said that the government is not under an obligation to do that. So the way we have interpreted it - in the last ten minutes although very briefly - is that this court is affirming the land rights which is very good but they are saying that the government does not have the duty essentially to protect those land rights. I would say it's very likely that we will go to the CCJ, I would also say that it's very likely that the government will wish to go to the CCJ on the part of the appeal that they lost."

"What is your reaction to the decision?"

Gregorio Choq - Executive Director, SATIM
"It's bittersweet I think - at least the court has affirmed that we have rights to the land, that we are owners to the land and that we have rights to those lands as properly defined under the constitution. So in terms of the rights, I believe that we can proceed to protect those rights even if the government doesn't see it fit."

"So will you be taking advice in terms of the possibility for certain constitutional rights?"

Gregorio Choq
"Absolutely, this is not the end here - we are going to take this definitely to the CCJ."

Practical Significance Of Judgment?

So, that’s the situation; the Court of Appeal has reaffirmed the rights of the Indigenous Maya communities of the south. But, it has reversed the orders by Former CJ Conteh, effectively removing the obligations of the Government to protect those rights.

And interestingly enough, the Court agreed with GOB’s arguments that in line with the Petroleum Act, the Mines and Minerals Act, and the Forest Act, the Government retains ownership and control of any lands where natural resources and minerals are found after exploration has been done. Their grievance was that Former CJ Conteh failed to take proper judicial notice of these laws and their implications.

That is significant because US Capital Energy wants to conduct oil exploration within the Sarstoon Temash National Park, and SATIIM is trying to block them with an injunction, which is yet to be scheduled for hearing.

In that context, the media asked attorney Antoinette Moore about the implications of the judgment on this and other matters which surround the lands which the Maya Communities are claiming.

Here’s how that conversation went:

Antoinette Moore - Attorney for the Maya Leaders Alliance
"At the time I don't think I can say very much in terms of that. The court of appeal meets every March, June and October - those are the sessions, however they can meet out of session for any reason to deliver a judgment that perhaps wasn't ready in June - they can meet at any time. Obviously there are some interesting issues around the timing because I have filed an application for contempt which is to be heard on Monday with respect to this very judgment, with contempt with the government not obeying the court order. So we shall see what will happen on Monday and I can see why you asked that question, I don't think I have a good answer for you thought."

"Being as dynamic as of late, how do you move forward - that you have a judgment in your favor in essence but things can change rather quickly."

Antoinette Moore
"I think it's a question for the Mayan community - the issues of the Rosewood extraction that comes directly from Maya lands - the issue of US Capital that is directly on Maya lands and preventing people from moving about in their own property. There are - as you said - many dynamic issues right on the ground and I think that this is going to be an ongoing, unfolding process that we are all going to have to observe. I have obviously advised my clients in respect to the law."

Explaining the time and long delay, the President of the Court of Appeal unreservedly apologized to the litigants explaining that this case was particularly complex and time-consuming. Looking at the length of their judgment, it would seem exactly that, but also, the President also explained that recently, the Appeal Court has been called upon to deal with an increase in complex cases such as this on.

It is also notable that in his conclusion, Justice of Appeal Morrison was of the opinion that Governments to come must recognize that in Belize’s history, all forms of governments past have respected the claims to land by the Maya people. He said, quote,

“The Ten-Point Agreement, as well as Act 2 of 2001, which closely followed it, are both of a piece, in my view, with what has in fact been a historic tendency towards recognition of the rights of the Maya. It is to be hoped that this tendency will continue beyond this litigation.”
End Quote.

Channel 7

Past information on this legal action....

Re: Long-Pending, Major Maya Judgment Handed Down [Re: Marty] #469208
07/30/13 04:51 AM
07/30/13 04:51 AM
Joined: Oct 1999
Posts: 80,387
oregon, spr
Marty Offline OP

Marty  Offline OP

Mayan Leaders Who Want Out Of Land Rights Court Action

On Thursday, 7News showed you the long anticipated judgment from the Court of Appeal in relation to the Appeal by the Government of Belize on the Maya Land Rights case.

The Maya Communities of the south won in the Supreme Court hear before former Chief Justice Abdulai Conteh, when he ruled that they had customary land rights over their ancestral lands, and he also ordered that the Government of Belize should also take mandatory steps to protect those rights.

Well, in the judgment from the Court of Appeal, it was found that while Maya Land Rights can and do exist, GOB had no such obligation to uphold them.

The attorney for the Maya Communities, Antoinette Moore filed an application for contempt against the Government in the Supreme Court, in which the complaint was that the Government was not respecting an injunction granted by the Former CJ Conteh stopping them from issuing any permits to conduct any kinds of commercial activity without the explicit consent of the Maya Communities.

This application was to be heard today, and when the Chief Justice called it up, Moore informed the court that her clients wished to withdraw the application. That withdrawal was granted and the matter was dismissed.

Moore explained to us outside of court that her clients decided that in the light of the Appeal Court judgment, they felt that their resources would be better spent dealing with how they will move forward with the bigger case.

But, there are 4 former Alcaldes from the south who are complaining that they wished to be removed from the case. They showed up at court today after getting an email, and no other notification, that they were expected to be present for the contempt proceedings.

Their issue is that they are no longer associated with the Maya Leaders Alliance, but they are still being used as claimants without their consent.

Today, the former Chairman of the Alliance explained the issue to us today:

Ligorio Coy - Former Chairman, Maya Leaders Alliance
"We made all effort to be here because I received an email where I read that the Mayan alliance want to take back the government to court and when I read that document - it's a contempt of court and we were not informed and they are using my name out there on the claimant's list. I'm very concerned because I don't know what is happening and I would like to listen and get to know more of what is transpiring with these guys; they should have informed me. I wrote a letter and I scanned it and emailed it to their attorney asking them to remove my name because I don't want to continue being a claimant. I will wait for their response whether they will remove my name or not. Then I might think what steps I should take again to remove my name because I am not presently with these organizations."

The former Alcaldes say that they will continue to write the lead attorneys, and they will try to speak with them on this issue.

Channel 7

Re: Long-Pending, Major Maya Judgment Handed Down [Re: Marty] #469347
08/01/13 04:54 AM
08/01/13 04:54 AM
Joined: Oct 1999
Posts: 80,387
oregon, spr
Marty Offline OP

Marty  Offline OP

Mayan Leaders Lament Appeals Court Decision

The Court of Appeals handed down its split decision on the Mayan Land rights case a week ago, and on Monday The Toledo Alcaldes Association gathered community members and leaders to review it. According to a press release, over 300 leaders from all the Maya villages in Toledo converged at the Julian Cho Technical High School near Punta Gorda to digest the decision.

And today, have come out with their collective position. A release from the group says, they are pleased that the court has reaffirmed their right to own their lands. It adds, quote,

“With this fourth favourable ruling in nine years, we are confident going forward that our land rights are clearly and firmly established.”

But, the statement also says they are quote,

“disappointed that the court failed to understand the discrimination and harm the government has subjected us to by denying the validity of our customary rights for decades,”
end quote.

It adds that the Leaders were also deeply apprehensive about the section of the decision that absolves government from protecting those rights and titling Maya lands. A unanimous endorsement was given to appeal that aspect of the decision to the Caribbean Court of Justice.

Channel 7

Portofino Resort- Now with a new BEACH BAR!!
Click for excellent scuba lessons with Elbert Greer!
Chaa Creek is an award-winning luxury Belize Resort, rated as one of the worlds best Eco Lodges. We are a pioneer in adventure travel to Belize since 1981!
Maruba Beach Klub and Spa is the premiere Secret Beach spa and restaurant located on the crystal blue waters of the Caribbean Sea at the center of Secret Beach, Belize
First Class Accommodations for the Budget Traveler
First Class Accommodations for the Budget Traveler

Things to do
Specials & Events
SPTB Calendar of Events

Daily News
Daily Weather

Classified Ads
San Pedro Sun
Ambergris Today
SP Town Council
Channel 7
Channel 5
Love FM
The Reporter
TV Newscasts
Radio Stations

Click for our
Search thousands of Belizean-only websites
To Get Your Questions Answered

Event Guides
Event Calendar
Specials & Events
Things to Do
Cayo Event Calendar

San Pedro Scoop!
Tia Chocolate
My Beautiful Belize
I-Travel Belize
Belize Adventure
Belize Hub
Romantic Travel
Belize Happy Adventures
Conch Creative
Caribbean Culture & Lifestyle
More Blogs...
Search thousands of Belizean-only websites
White Sands Dive Shop - 5 Star PADI Dive Facility - Daily diving, SCUBA instruction and Snorkeling
Caribbean Inspired All Natural Condiments & Spice Blends, Over 100 are Gluten Free!
We handle all aspects of the purchase of your Real Estate in Belize. From in depth property searches to your final closing.
Click for Ian Anderson's Caves Branch, Welcome to a World of Adventure
Lil Alphonse has snorkel equipment to fit anyone as well as Marine Park Tickets and flotation devices to assist those not as experienced.
Coastal Xpress offers a daily scheduled ferry run to most resorts, restaurants and private piers on the island of Anbergris Caye. We also offer  private and charter water taxi service.
Cayo Espanto
Click for Cayo Espanto, and have your own private island
More Links
Click for exciting and adventurous tours of Belize with Katie Valk!
ShoutChat Box
Who's Online Now
0 registered members (), 69 guests, and 0 spiders.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Forum Statistics
Most Online7,413
Nov 7th, 2021 HELP! Visitor Center Goods & Services San Pedro Town Message Board Lodging Diving Fishing Things to Do History Maps Phonebook Belize Business Directory Picture of the Day

The opinions and views expressed on this board are the subjective opinions of Ambergris Caye Message Board members
and not of the Ambergris Caye Message Board its affiliates, or its employees.

Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.1